to Catalyst on-line. United Methodist (UM) seminarians have been receiving
Catalyst in their mail boxes since 1973.
What is Catalyst?
issues of Catalyst are mailed each academic year to some 5,000 UM theological
students in more than 100 seminaries in the U.S.A.
is a project of A Foundation for Theological Education (AFTE).
What is the John Wesley Fellowship Program?
year AFTE awards up to five John Wesley Fellowships to assist gifted United
Methodists in their doctoral studies at the finest universities.
back issues of Catalyst are now available on-line.
is free for UM seminarians, and is available to all others for $5 per year.
“Our doctrine and our discipline” was a phrase common to early Methodists,
including John Wesley and Francis Asbury. Both terms were crucial to the
new movement, but they had significantly different connotations then than
they do for many today.
“Doctrine” meant much more than concepts about God and God’s work in the
world. True to its root meaning, it did denote what Methodists teach. But
it was an eminently “practical divinity,” and that in two senses. First,
doctrine is like a map that shows the way to salvation—what salvation is,
how to receive it, and how to grow in it. It tells us about God’s promise
of forgiveness and new life, and describes that new life. It shows the relationship
between grace and faith, and how both are grounded in and lead to love.
Second, doctrine is like a portrait that paints a picture of God. Drawing
on Scripture, it tells us what God has done in creation, in the story of
Israel, and in Jesus Christ. It sets before us the promises of God. And in
doing all this, it provides a picture of God’s character, which is centered
in love. When we love God, it is doctrine (and the Scripture which underlies
it) that enables us to know who God is.
If “doctrine” had to do with the goal of salvation, “discipline” referred
to the means. Salvation for Wesley was by grace through faith. Discipline
constituted those practices which helped nurture our faith by keeping our
hearts and lives focused on God and our neighbor.
The word “discipline” is often used today in ways that encourage misunderstanding
of what it meant for Wesley. For many United Methodists, “the discipline”
means The Book of Discipline, a sizable volume dealing with church
polity. But while today the word “discipline” brings to mind the rules for
organizing a local church or a national church agency, to the early Methodists
“discipline” was about how you live your life. The American version of the
original “Methodist Discipline” is found inside The Book of Discipline,
and is about two and a half pages long.
In American culture “discipline” often refers to punishment or a restraint
on our activity. Americans generally prefer a word like “freedom” to a word
like “discipline.” We tend to see ourselves as essentially free, and do not
like limitations on that freedom.
Wesley sees our situation differently. We are not simply free to do as we
choose, because we are bound by sin. Our choices reflect our character; because
we are sinners, all that we think, say, or do is compromised by sin.
Wesley believed discipline was essential for us to be free from sin and free
to be the people God created us to be. He warns that “whatever doctrine is
preached, where there is not discipline, it cannot have its full effect upon
the hearers,” hence none can “be a real Christian, without the help of Christian
discipline.” (J. Wesley, “Causes of the Inefficacy of Christianity,” 8).
This discipline consisted of such things as daily prayer and searching the
scriptures, regular participation in worship, including the Lord’s Supper,
and service to our neighbor. The early Methodists met weekly in small groups
called classes to give an account of how things had gone the preceding week
as they sought to keep the discipline.
The Methodist discipline was both like and unlike the discipline of an athlete
or musician. It did involve regular practices, and certainly the more people
prayed or served their neighbor, the better they got at doing them. But Wesley
was convinced that, as we engage in these practices, the Holy Spirit enables
us to grow in the knowledge and love of God. Thus, the discipline is more
than honing our skills. It is most fundamentally about opening our lives
to the transforming work of God. The desire for God and the life God gives,
as shown by Methodist doctrine, was the central motivation for keeping the
By Henry H. Knight III, Donald and Pearl Wright Professor of Wesleyan
Saint Paul School of Theology